Frequent Crier Miles

Originally appeared in the May 1999 issue of the ABA Journal.

Harmless Error - A Truly Minority View on the Law

Frequent Crier Miles

BY ANDREW J. McCLURG

With complaints against airlines up 26 percent last year, Northwest picked a bad time to trap passengers in their seats for up to 11 hours during a January storm.

Things got worse when American’s pilots staged a “sick-out,” stranding thousands of angry fliers. (Official comment of the International Association of Pilots With Really Weak Immune Systems: “We were sick as dogs. No Kidding, Coughing, sneezing, scratchy throat, that aching feeling. It was awful.”)

Whatever the cause, both incidents were bad breaks for the airlines in light of recent marketing studies showing “vassalage” and “ruination of life” as two airline practices that annoy consumers.

Now Congress is getting into the act. Besieged with complaints about everything from getting no explanations for flight cancellations to being forced to hand babies over to security screeners at metal detectors, members of Congress have proposed a comprehensive Air Traveler’s Bill of Rights.

Not surprisingly, the airlines don’t like the proposal. Industry lobbyists have come up with an alternative bill of rights they assert is more balanced and fair to both sides. Here it is:

Air Traveler’s Bill of Rights (nonchangeable without penalty)

1. You have the right to remain silent. In fact, we prefer it that way. Please keep your trap shut the entire trip. If you choose to give up this right, anything you say can and will be used as an excuse to ram your head into the overhead compartment.

2. You have the right to arrive at the airport and find we canceled your flight. Why? You don’t really want to know. It was canceled two months before you made the reservation. Truthfully, we haven’t even looked into buying a plane for that flight. We’ve also canceled your credit cards, haircutting appointment and big date for this weekend. Right now, we’re towing your car.

3. You have the right to have an attorney present during check-in, provided she buys the most expensive business-class ticket on this week’s Hot 100 price list. If your attorney cannot afford one, you need a more successful attorney.

4. You have the right to have a drink cart parked between you and the bathroom at all times. Moving a drink cart with intent to urinate is a federal felony.

5. You have the right to be pepper-sprayed if you verbally abuse airline personnel with epithets such as, “Could you please help me? I’m begging you.”

6. You have the right of all Americans to be treated rudely and with contempt.

7. You have the right to a free radiological examination of your infant children. Since you whined so much about having to hand the totsters over to members of our crack security squad, just pop ‘em down on the X-ray machine belt and pick them up on the other side.

8. You have a right to have your knees surgically removed so you can fit in a seat designed for very tiny toy people with no knees.

9. You have the right to redeem the declining value of your frequent flier miles for selected bus travel in the Midwest, provided all travel be completed before the first date to fall on the date beginning on the date of travel.

10. You have no right to your luggage. Just forget about it.

Yeah, Yeah, Yeah

Originally appeared in the June 1999 issue of the ABA Journal.

Harmless Error - A Truly Minority View on the Law

Yeah, Yeah, Yeah

BY ANDREW J. McCLURG

Some people blamed Yoko Ono for the Beatles’ breakup, but now comes the discovery that the demise of the Fab Four was rooted in a bizarre artistic dispute over the recording of Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band.

John Lennon had a keen interest in legal matters, particularly those involving searches and seizures. His various legal run-ins gave him the idea to record a concept album about—you won’t believe this—the law. Unfortunately, the other moptops hated the idea. They rejected his proposed title of Sgt. Pepper & Associates, Limited Liability Partnership: If this Record Doesn’t Hit Number One, You Don’t Owe Us a Dime.

That was the beginning of the end. John was bitterly disappointed as he watched his idea being dismantled night after night during those famous recording sessions at Abbey Road. For the first time ever, here in John’s own words that I made up, are his original psychelegadelic versions of some of the greatest songs in rock history:

Lucy In the Sky With Diamonds

“Rumor had it this was some kind of drug song, but that wasn’t it at all. I wrote it about an admiralty case. Lucy was the name of a barge. The first verse went like this (strumming guitar):

Picture yourself in a boat on a river, with tangerine trees and marmalade skies, suddenly a submerged log rips through the hull, the navigable waters grow incredibly high.

It’s original title was Lucy Underwater With Multiple Liens and Judgments.“

Being For the Benefit of Mr. Kite

“A negligence case, with a tricky charitable immunity issue included. For the benefit of Mr. Kite, the defendants staged a show one night—on trampolines of all things.”

“As if that wasn’t reckless enough, they induced plaintiff to jump over men and horses and, with conscious indifference to his welfare, through a hogshead of real fire. There weren’t even any warnings on the hogshead.”

Fixing A Hole

“Paul wrote this one. He had this line going through his head (singing), I’m fixing a hole where the rain gets in and I told him to add to keep my tenant from suing me. I wanted it to be a tale of landlord-tenant oppression. When Paul sang the chorus line, Where it will go-oh-oh-oh, I said ‘Paul, yer daft. Change it to Implied warranty of habitabilitee-ee-ee-ee’ but he wouldn’t have it.”

A Day In the Life

“My favorite cut on the LP because it stays fairly true to my original idea, which was to track the thoughts of a down and out personal injury lawyer who starts each morning searching the newspaper for clients. The first version went like this (reading lyrics):

I read the news today.
Oh boy!
A wrongful death case. Victim didn’t notice that the lights had changed.
Eyewitnesses: A crowd of people stood and stared.
Economic damages: Victim may or may not be from House of Lords. Nobody is really sure.
I read the news today.
Oh boy!
Four thousand holes in Blackburn, Lancashire. The mother of all products liability cases.
Note to self: Will need expert witness. Holes are very small. Have to count them all.

Lest anyone think I’m showing disrespect to the Fab Four, I feel obliged to point out: I love you Beatles, oh yes I do, I love you Beatles, I love you true . . .

Contract Sports

Originally appeared in the July 1999 issue of the ABA Journal.

Harmless Error - A Truly Minority View on the Law

Contract Sports

BY ANDREW J. McCLURG

As sports fans look forward to another season of exciting NFL football, the slow process of coming to contract terms with this year’s draft picks continues. Why does it take so long to sign players to contract? These sports law insights help explain it:

High-Low. As with all contract negotiations, the basic negotiating strategy in the NFL is the high-low method. The draftee’s sports agent starts high and the NFL team starts low. Each side compromises until agreement is reached. Here’s a typical negotiation:

Agent: We demand a $50 million signing bonus, title to the stadium, a new Ferrari and renaming of the city after my client.

NFL team: Hundred dollar Wendy’s gift certificate, free stadium parking on game days, new Huffy ten-speed and we’ll rename the offensive line coach’s cat after your client.

Agent: $40 million signing bonus, all stadium concessions, vintage Corvette with fuel injected engine and rename a major highway after my client.

NFL team: Ten thousand dollars, all non-alcoholic beer concessions, vintage Pinto with fuel injected passenger compartment and rename the alley behind the mayor’s house after your client.

This continues for months, sometimes through a bitter training camp holdout, until the parties agree on what they were willing to accept at the beginning.

First Round Pick Exception. A major negotiating exception exists for first round draft picks. Signing these players is seen as so vital to a team’s success that they get just about whatever they demand.

Look at the compensation package obtained by a hot first-round quarterback in the ‘99 draft: “In consideration for his running and throwing, Player shall receive the Chrysler Corporation, Bill Gates’ checkbook and a major country to be named later.”

Incentives. NFL teams assume a huge risk when signing players of unproven pro potential to fat contracts. Lots of big bucks signees turn out to be busts. As a protective measure, NFL lawyers now routinely insert incentive clauses in contracts that provide for higher payments upon players attaining specified goals. Here’s a commonly used clause:

“Player shall be paid incentive bonuses according to the following schedule: 1. Avoiding DWI charges: $10,000; Avoiding drug charges: $100,000; Avoiding assault charges: $500,000; Avoiding Three Strikes and Your Out sentencing: $1 million.”

Sports Agents. Although sports agents get criticized for being stubborn negotiators, they can’t help it. It’s apparently part of their genetic makeup as I learned last week when visiting a sports agent friend. He told his kid to take out the trash and this colloquy ensued:

Kid: I’ll do it for twenty bucks and unlimited Nintendo privileges.

Agent dad: You’re outta your mind. I’ll give you fifty cents.

Kid: You insult me. And after all I’ve done for this organization. Perhaps my services are no longer valued here. Maybe I should call the Hammersteins next door and see if they’re in the market for an exceptional kid.

Agent dad: Alright, alright. Five bucks, but that’s my final offer.

Kid: Dad, I’m going to pretend I didn’t hear that.

While we anxiously await the season opener, I have a great programming tip for ESPN—televise the contract negotiations. No need to worry about losing viewers with a boring defensive struggle. Rumor has it the negotiations can get quite offensive.

Hiring Squeeze

Originally appeared in the August 1999 issue of the ABA Journal.

Harmless Error - A Truly Minority View on the Law

Hiring Squeeze

BY ANDREW J. McCLURG

According to Kimm Walton’s popular book, Guerrilla Tactics For Getting the Legal Job of Your Dreams, when legal interviewers ask tough questions like “What’s your greatest weakness?” it’s not so much because they want to know the answer as to test your ability to handle pressure. So avoid baring your soul with honest answers like “Life terrifies me” or “I hate the law.”

Walton wisely advises job applicants to prepare answers to tough questions in advance, but if she’s right about employers intentionally putting us on the spot, a more aggressive response may be in order. People are stressed out enough at job interviews. We don’t need interviewers trying to make us look bad. As Americans, we enjoy the basic, inalienable right to do that for ourselves.

Fight back! Try the brand new interviewing strategy designed with today’s pugnacious young lawyer in mind: Intimidation. Answer all tough questions with the goal of making the employer afraid NOT to hire you. For example, the next time a law firm asks, “Do you have what it takes to bring business into the firm?,” say, “Of course. It’s in the trunk of my car. Just tell me whose business you want.”

Here are some of the toughest legal job interview questions according to Guerrilla Tactics and some Gorilla Tactics for answering them:

Q. Tell us about yourself.

A. Which one. Fred’s been bad. He can’t come out today.

Q. Did you get into any other law schools?

A. Plenty. In fact, I got into every Ivy League school except Columbia. Now there’s a school that deserves its top ranking. It has the finest alarm system in the nation.

Q. What’s your greatest weakness?

A. An unquenchable thirst for vengeance. I’ve spent years in therapy battling it, but always end up trying to get even with my inner child.

Q. Where do you see yourself five years from now?

A. As a highly-paid member of your firm or possibly at the Super-Max Federal Correctional Facility in Colorado.

Q. What’s your greatest strength?

A. I can carry a rocket-propelled grenade launcher in one hand.

Q. Why didn’t you get an offer from your last employer?

A. I might have. It was hard to understand what he was yelling from behind the locked door.

Q. Why aren’t your grades better?

A. Because my professors, like most people around me, possibly including you, are engaged in a massive conspiracy to persecute me unjustly. I know because Hillary Clinton, who lives inside my head, told me so.

Q. Who else are you interviewing with?

A. I’ve been offered several jobs, but they’re not legal positions, at least not in this country.

Q. Why should we hire you?

A. Ha, ha. Don’t, and find out.

Obviously, this strategy is not for everyone. It’s only for the criminally insane. For everyone else, I suggest sticking with the advice in Guerrilla Tactics.

Heal Thy Self

Originally appeared in the September 1999 issue of the ABA Journal.

Harmless Error - A Truly Minority View on the Law

Heal Thy Self

BY ANDREW J. McCLURG

With Congress debating a patient’s bill of rights, it seemed like a good time to reprise one of the most requested Harmless Error columns of the last four years.

Legal disputes arising from the denial of medical coverage by managed health care organizations are on the rise. HMOs face a difficult challenge in making coverage decisions because they must delicately balance two conflicting interests: providing quality health care for their patients at a reasonable cost and hoarding as much money as possible.

Here are some of the more common questions about coverage and some standard responses from HMOs:

Q. How do I know if my condition is covered?

A. Check the “Exclusions” section of your plan description. Typical services excluded from coverage include dental care, cosmetic surgery and anything costing more than ten dollars. Our preferred method for determining whether a condition is covered is through an autopsy. However, before seeing a coroner, you must get a referral from your primary care physician.

Q. Is mental health treatment covered?

A. Are you crazy? That stuff is expensive. However, to serve the mental health needs of our loyal plan participants we’ve set up a therapy help line. Simply dial our toll free number and select from the following menu of sensitive pre-recorded treatments:

1. Quit Your Whining.
2. It’s Your Mother’s Fault.
3. Dump the Jerk.
4. Those Strange Voices In Your Head Aren’t Real.
5. Smiling Your Way Through Deep, Dark Depression.

Q. Is Viagra covered?

A. Only under the extended plan. Ha. Kidding. The real answer is: NO. Due to rising pharmaceutical costs, we’ve been forced to make minor adjustments in our prescription coverage. Effective immediately, the following prescriptions are no longer covered: the most popular drugs selected by physicians for effective treatment of the most common ailments suffered by human beings.

Q. How can I get in to see an “Out-of-Network” provider as described in my plan?

A. You can’t. That’s a typo. The coverage is for “Out-of-Work” providers. They’re much cheaper.

Q. What happens if coverage is denied, but I desperately need treatment?

A. We recognize the need to resolve coverage disputes expeditiously. For this reason, we’ve established a speedy automated appeal procedure.

Step one: Request EZ Complaint Form 5436.

Step two: Fully complete all 72 pages, including attached “Humiliating Intrusion Into Your Personal Life and Medical History Form 7435.”

Step three: Conveniently deposit the completed form in any nearby trash receptacle. While you relax in the comfort of your home, your claim is being automatically processed and denied.

Q. I’m blind. Does your company show special sensitivity in handling claims by the sight-impaired?

A.

Q. My plan excludes coverage for pre-existing conditions. What does that include?

A. The new industry-wide definition for pre-existing condition is: “Any illness, disease, infirmity, malady, affliction, ailment, injury, sore throat, cough, scraped knee, fever, infection, broken bone, concussion, kidney stone, pregnancy, tumor, hemorrhage, psychosis, missing limb, ache, pain, or gripe of any kind arising on or before the date on which medical treatment is sought.”

Q. Does my plan cover home visits by a designated provider?

A. Ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha … stop, you’re killing me.

Suzy’s Re-dress

Originally appeared in the October 1999 issue of the ABA Journal.

Harmless Error - A Truly Minority View on the Law

Suzy’s Re-dress

BY ANDREW J. McCLURG

My daughter’s litigiously delinquent pal, Suzy Spikes, just turned 13, causing concern in the neighborhood over the effect of adolescence on Suzy’s already temperamental nature.

Fortunately, most of the new locks, guard dogs and lawyers on retainer proved unnecessary. Apart from a few hundred histrionic outbursts, three Officer Needs Assistance calls and a minor incident in which Suzy bound Billy Johnson with electrical cord until he conceded she was the nicest girl in the seventh grade, Suzy’s adjustment to teen status has gone surprisingly smoothly.

Until last week, when her middle school imposed a new uniform dress code. On the first day, school officials determined Suzy’s outfit was out of compliance. In response to being sent home, Suzy organized a demonstration in the parking lot in which mobs of seventh-grade girls chanted “No ex post facto plaid” and sang “We Shall Overcome Hunter Green” until administrators reluctantly granted Suzy a hearing.

Principal Geeker represented the school. Suzy appeared pro se. It was a mismatch.

Q. Suzy, you have the uniform dress code in front of you. Show me where it says students are permitted to wear leopard-print tights.

A. Doesn’t say you can’t.

Q. Platform combat boots?

A. Doesn’t say you can’t.

Q. Faux rabbit fur scarf?

A. I stand by my previous answers. If the dorks who wrote this hideously unfair and stupid dress code wanted to outlaw my everyday wear, they should have said so. How was I supposed to know?

Q. It just so happens I’m the dork who wrote this hideously unfair and stupid dress code.

A. Then I should inform you that anything you say can and will be used against you. This state has strict laws protecting children.

Q. Sigh.

Suzy’s case consisted of the testimony of several other adolescent girls who swore under oath they would literally “die” if they couldn’t wear their new $50 teeshirts from Abercrombie & Fitch. Then came Suzy’s turn to examine the principal.

Q. Tell me, Principal Geeker, if that’s your real name, with all the problems facing our schools, why did you decide to dedicate your career to ruining the life of an innocent 13-year-old child?

A. I assure you the purpose of the dress code was not to ruin your life.

Q. Lies! Distortion!

A. Suzy, please.

Q. Objection! Badgering counsel. How can I possibly be expected to defend myself when every move I make I get tormented by The Man?

A. Overruled.

Q. Fine. Send me to the electric chair.

A. Sigh.

Suzy’s closing argument was compelling. She made an impassioned plea for liberty, individuality and Doc Martens, cried real tears, threw up on the vice principal, and threatened a class action on behalf of all similarly situated hormonally impaired and garment-oppressed 13-year-olds. Principal Geeker has called in sick for three weeks, so disposition remains pending.

Say What?

Originally appeared in the November 1999 issue of the ABA Journal.

Harmless Error - A Truly Minority View on the Law

Say What?

BY ANDREW J. McCLURG

The hearsay rule and its many exceptions are a marvel of complexity. The confusion starts with the basic definition of hearsay as any statement made out of court “offered to prove the truth of the matter asserted.” If an out-of-court statement is offered for a purpose other than proving truth, it’s admissible.

Some lawyers believe all statements are offered to prove their truth and that opponents sometimes subvert the rule by misrepresenting the real purpose for which evidence is offered.

This allegedly occurred in a recent criminal case where John was on trial for killing Bill. The prosecution pinned its case on a post-it note seized from John’s refrigerator that said “To Do: 1. Pick up dry cleaning. 2. Empty litter box. 3. Kill Bill.”

The defense cried hearsay, but the prosecutor argued indignantly that the note wasn’t being offered to prove John killed Bill, but only to show John has good penmanship, is an organized person and has potential as a hit songwriter because he can rhyme “Bill” and “kill.” The judge readily agreed and admitted the note, but cured any problem by telling the jury not to think about it.

Of course, John’s note could also come in as an Admission of a Party-Opponent, but why the law gives credence to these stick-in-the-muds is a mystery. In any event, all lawyers can use a refresher on the hearsay exceptions. Here are two for starters:

Records of Vital Statistics. Diverse constituencies attended the drafting convention for the hearsay rules, including a faction of rabid sports fans with a love of sports trivia. These diehards insisted on a hearsay exception for records of vital statistics such as most RBIs, most yards rushing and most third down conversions by a player facing mandatory sentencing.

Opponents argued the exception was unnecessary because such statistics can come in under other exceptions, such as that for dying declarations: “Gasp. Most touchdown passes … cough … cough … Dan Marino … ackkk.”

But the determined sports fans won. Unfortunately, lots of precious courtroom time is wasted over squabbles about whether a statistic is “vital.” Cubs fans think their stats are vital, Knicks fans theirs, it goes on and on. At one recent trial the litigants got so rowdy they began throwing snow balls at the jury and beer sales had to be shut down.

Mental, Emotional or Physical Condition. Another important hearsay exception is for statements regarding a person’s mental, emotional or physical condition. Under this rule, just about any gripe concerning what ails a person is admissible. “My back is killing me,” “I think I’m gonna throw up” and “Oh no, I have a huge zit” all come in. The problem is no one wants to listen to this complaining in the first place, much less admit it into evidence.

However, sometimes a closer look reveals evidentiary significance in everyday whining, as the above examples demonstrate when studied in context:

“My back is killing me. I’m not carrying that body one more step.”

“I think I’m gonna throw up. Maybe I should cut down my intake of illegal narcotics.”

“Oh no, I have a huge zit. I hope no one recognizes me from the liquor store robbery.”

Next month we’ll cover the hearsay exception for “excited utterances,” concentrating on lawyers’ responses to the statement: “I’m leaving the firm and taking all the clients with me.”

Tot Tech

Originally appeared in the December 1999 issue of the ABA Journal.

Harmless Error - A Truly Minority View on the Law

Tot Tech

BY ANDREW J. McCLURG

In our high-tech information society, product manufacturers are well aware of the importance of product release announcements for generating buzz in the marketplace.

Lawyers often play a crucial role in compiling and reviewing new product documentation prior to its release. Sometimes it goes to their heads, as two Silicon Valley lawyers recently demonstrated:

Product Release Announcement

The development team of Todd and Rita Billington are delighted to announce the release of their new product, Kate, on Wednesday, 2:23 a.m., at Memorial Hospital. Processing difficulties delayed the product release one day, a snag that caused concern and prolonged wailing among the Rita Division of the Billington team.

Product specifications:

Weight: 7 lbs
Length: 20 inches
Memory: none
Connections: cordless once removed from packaging

Although customer response has been warm, critics have accused Kate of being over-engineered and lacking several important features called for in the original user requirements documentation, including a simplified user interface and automatic scream-saver when not in use.

The Billington team resisted investor pressure to outsource the development, insisting on maintaining full creative and legal control over the product and its source code. However, negotiations are already underway with several neighborhood independent contractors to outsource some future product maintenance and support on big nights out.

Kate comes equipped with many features demanded by today’s consumers of high quality tots: drooling, gurgling, cooing, chubby thighs and the prettiest pair of blue input units on the market today. The product is easily booted and rebooted using adorable tiny shoes from the Gap Kids typically delivered by outside suppliers.

Management is currently tackling what it terms “minor bugs” with Kate, including complaints that the product’s dual ports open frequently and without warning. Experts predict the problem will correct itself within 30 to 36 months, the estimated time frame to RAM the idea of using a toilet into long term memory. Until then, the problem is being addressed using extra-absorbent softwear.

Looking for a hard drive? How about an impossible one? Packing Kate’s 300 essential travel accessories, mastering the tech support to install her car seat, and negotiating traffic while faced backwards waving a cookie is guaranteed to make even a trip to the grocery store the hardest drive of your life.

Users must also beware of the virulent “Colic” virus, which rapidly disables all product functions except the sound card.

The product comes with a limited warranty: “Product is warranted to perform reasonably well for 13 years, at which time all operating systems will suddenly crash and product will function erratically and unpredictably. This is normal. Do NOT attempt to return product to place of manufacture as serious injury could result.”

While management irons out these complaints, the Billington team’s primary focus is to make Kate at least modestly compliant by Y2K. Currently, Kate is ignoring all user commands.

(Congratulations to new product owners Markus Weber and Wendy Nather, Chicago, IL, whose real birth announcement inspired this one.)

Cupid’s Covenant

Originally appeared in the February 2000 issue of the ABA Journal.

Harmless Error - A Truly Minority View on the Law

Cupid’s Covenant

BY ANDREW J. McCLURG

With Valentine’s Day looming, it’s a good time to get some legal perspective on the whole relationship thing, especially the breaking up part. We need to face the fact that despite our hopelessly unrealistic expectations, most relationships don’t last.

Breaking up has serious consequences for both parties which need to be considered in advance, while equal bargaining power still exists. Never enter into a relationship unless BOTH parties have executed the…

Relationship Termination Agreement

The undersigned prospective lovebirds, being of sound mind but probably not for long, enter into the following agreement to govern their respective rights and responsibilities in the event of a partnership dissolution:

1. I agree not to go around blabbing the embarrassing secrets and quirks you confessed to me in strict confidence on the silly assumption that I wasn’t going to some day hate your guts. Breach of this paragraph shall constitute tortious interference with prospective advantageous relationships.

2. Within 10 days of the contract termination, I covenant to place 25 melodramatic phone calls to you, at least half of which shall occur late at night while I am intoxicated. Just to remind you that I still have strong feelings for you, at least five of these calls shall qualify as “harassment” under applicable law.

3. I shall retain any and all cards, gifts and other items of endearment supplied during the contract term for one full calendar year, at which time I may dissolve them in sulphuric acid. I shall re-read all cards on at least five occasions, and hereby bind myself to feel nostalgic, wistful and wonder whether we made a mistake on each such occasion.

4. When asked why the contract was terminated, I shall falsely represent: “It was a mutual decision. We’re still good friends.”

5. Upon breakup, you shall return all items of personal property belonging to me, with immediate attention to any videotapes made during the course of said contract.

6. It is understood that the next person I date shall be less attractive than you and that this provision shall be strictly construed against the datee. I agree not to date your best friends, even though I think a couple of them are really hot.

7. Friends shall be split as follows: (fill in blanks) ________ is my friend. Do not even attempt to speak to him/her, as he/she is subject to an express condition subsequent to curse you loudly in the event of a contract breach. ________ can be your friend, since I’ve always found him/her affected and annoying. Everyone else is my friend (choose one or more depending on property settlement) on Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays, alternate weekends and major holidays.

8. I agree not to hang out on “your turf,” including but not limited to your front porch and the alley behind your house, especially while on a date.

9. I covenant not to refer to any future contracting party as “Puppytoes” or “Yum-yum.”

10. I shall have the option of temporarily resuming the contract on at least two occasions after the breakup, at least one of which shall be initiated by a romantic chance encounter, preferably at someone’s wedding. It is understood that these contract renewals will be for short periods and end badly.

Cable Cartel

Originally appeared in the March 2000 issue of the ABA Journal.

Harmless Error - A Truly Minority View on the Law

Cable Cartel

BY ANDREW J. McCLURG

With cities threatening lawsuits and stiff fines for lousy service and millions of viewers flocking to satellite dishes, cable television companies have realized they need to upgrade their image. The giant, caring brain inside the cable industry’s public relations center has responded with this insert for next month’s bill:

Important Customer Information

It has come to our attention through your constant whining and complaining that some of you couch potatoes aren’t satisfied with our service. Apparently, you think we treat you shabbily. Well, of course we do. Why? Because we can.

Just kidding. We love our customers. That’s the reason we’re writing to tell you about some exciting new improvements, that and a paralyzing fear of government regulation:

New programming. We’re happy to report that last month’s 500 percent rate increase has allowed us to expand our programming to include many new and exciting channels:

(1) Empty Sky Network. See the sky live 24 hours a day.

(2) Bovine Growth Network. Watch cows mature from birth to adulthood.

(3) The Jones Channel (TJC). People with the last name “Jones” discuss their life experiences.

(4) TNT Network. Not Ted Turner’s outfit. We’re talking real TNT! Live detonations around the clock.

(5) Plus 27 more golf channels!

Help line. Have a question? Call us anytime. You won’t get to talk to a real human being because cable companies do not employ actual live workers. However, we do have a great new phone menu designed to demonstrate how completely we control your pitiful boobtube-watching lifestyles:

If you’re calling from a touch tone phone—and we know you are so don’t even think about pretending you’re not—press 1. Wait for static. Press 5. Wait for static. Press 3, 6 and 9 at the exact same time. Now press 4 and then 8 REALLY FAST. Wait for static.

Press 1 finger to nose. We’re not kidding. Do it. … (Whistling) … We’re not in any hurry. Are you? There, that’s better. Now press 2 and then the pound sign. Or 7. It doesn’t really matter.

To report a service outage, enter your phone number, street address, zip code and mail us a picture of your house with directions. Stay on the line. For billing questions, skip to our state of the art automated account system and, seriously, good luck. If you have a complaint, press the star sign and hang up. Go watch more TV and you’ll feel better.

If at any time you wish to repeat this menu, you must be a very bored and lonely person. Go watch more TV.

Service appointments. Experiencing a service interruption? No problem. We offer four convenient and reliable appointment slots to help you manage your busy schedule: Fall, Winter, Summer and Spring.

Pay-per-view. Some of our most special programming is available only on a pay-per-view basis. Sign up now for the “Thrilla in Ashtabula” for only $99.95. See the heavyweight grudge match of the century as Lennox Lewis defends his crown against some other guy TBA.

Our promise to you. We’re 100 percent committed to providing you intermittent sound and video images and a monthly bill. If you’re not completely satisfied, we encourage you to try out one of our competitors. Be sure to figure in interstate moving costs when comparing monthly rates.